Prof. Soo-yong Byun is a Professor of Education Theory and Policy, Demography, and Asian Studies at The Pennsylvania State University. He holds a joint appointment with the Social Science Research Institute as a co-funded faculty member and is also affiliated with Penn State’s Comparative and International Education Program. Prof. Byun’s research focuses on the sociology of education, international and comparative education, rural education, and educational policy analysis and program evaluation. His work has been published in leading peer-reviewed journals, also he has served on the editorial and advisory boards of several prominent journals. He received the 2021 Senior Outstanding Research Award from Penn State’s College of Education and served as President of the Korean American Educational Researchers Association from 2017 to 2018.
Title: Shadow Education as cultural capital? Evidence of intergenerational transmission in South Korea
Abstract: Research on shadow education or private supplementary education has expanded rapidly over the past two decades, documenting its growth, socioeconomic determinants, and consequences for academic achievement. A large body of scholarship shows that participation in private tutoring and supplementary instruction is strongly stratified by family background and often associated with improved test scores and educational attainment. While this literature has significantly advanced our understanding of who participates in shadow education and whether it “works” in academic terms, much less attention has been paid to how shadow education shapes broader educational processes and outcomes beyond achievement—such as educational transitions, intergenerational reproduction, and students’ experiences within mainstream schooling.
Responding to this gap, this session brings together three papers that examine the role of shadow education in shaping educational inequality and schooling experiences across diverse national contexts. Moving beyond a narrow focus on academic performance, the papers collectively address how shadow education operates as a stratifying mechanism embedded in institutional contexts, cultural expectations, and everyday schooling practices. Drawing on large-scale longitudinal and nationally representative datasets, the session highlights cross-national variation as well as within-country processes through which shadow education reproduces or reshapes inequality.
The first paper examines how shadow education shapes students’ transitions to higher education in Germany, Japan, and the United States. Using nationally representative panel data, the study engages two competing theoretical perspectives: a universal effects model, which posits that shadow education confers similar advantages across contexts, and a cross-national differences model, which emphasizes institutional variation in how shadow education is rewarded. The analysis focuses on whether shadow education mediates or amplifies socioeconomic disparities in access to higher education under distinct education systems. Findings reveal striking cross-national differences. In Germany, where early tracking and strong vocational pathways structure educational trajectories, shadow education has limited influence on college transitions. In Japan, shadow education facilitates access to university education within a relatively standardized and exam-oriented system. In contrast, in the United States, shadow education intensifies social selectivity in college admission, disproportionately benefiting socioeconomically advantaged students. These results demonstrate that the role of shadow education in reproducing or mitigating educational inequality is highly context-dependent and shaped by national institutional arrangements.
The second paper shifts attention to intergenerational processes by examining whether parents’ own participation in shadow education is transmitted to their children and whether children’s participation is subsequently rewarded within mainstream schooling. Using data from the Korean Educational Longitudinal Study of 2013, the study conceptualizes shadow education as a form of cultural capital that is learned, normalized, and strategically deployed across generations. The analysis investigates both the intergenerational continuity of shadow education participation and its association with children’s academic achievement, net of family socioeconomic status and prior performance. The findings provide important insights into how shadow education functions not merely as a short-term academic investment but as a durable family practice that contributes to the reproduction of educational advantage in the East Asian context.
The third paper examines how participation in shadow education shapes students’ perceptions of classroom teaching, again drawing on data from the Korean Educational Longitudinal Study of 2013. Rather than treating shadow education as separate from mainstream schooling, this study investigates how experiences in supplementary education influence students’ evaluations of their regular classroom teachers. The analysis tests whether students who participate in shadow education report systematically lower evaluations of teaching quality, even after accounting for academic performance, school characteristics, and family background. The findings suggest that shadow education may subtly reshape students’ expectations of instruction, potentially undermining the perceived effectiveness or legitimacy of mainstream classroom teaching.
Taken together, these three papers advance the literature on shadow education in several important ways. First, they broaden the scope of inquiry beyond academic achievement to include educational transitions, intergenerational reproduction, and students’ subjective experiences of schooling. Second, they demonstrate that the consequences of shadow education are deeply embedded in national institutional contexts, challenging universalistic interpretations of its effects. Third, they highlight shadow education as an integral—rather than peripheral—component of contemporary education systems, with implications for inequality, educational policy, and classroom dynamics. By integrating comparative and intergenerational perspectives with analyses of schooling experiences, this session provides a theoretically informed and empirically grounded account of how shadow education shapes educational inequality across contexts. The session will be of interest to scholars of comparative education, sociology of education, and education policy, as well as policymakers concerned with the expanding role and unintended consequences of private supplementary education worldwide.
https://ed.psu.edu/directory/dr-soo-yong-byun